Coach’s Checklist: Ordering a Custom Baseball Jersey for the Whole Roster

Coach’s Checklist: Ordering a Custom Baseball Jersey for the Whole Roster

Outfitting an entire team doesn’t have to feel like extra innings. With a clear process (and a reliable vendor), you can go from concept to delivery without last-minute scrambles. Use this step-by-step checklist to plan, proof, and place your team order for a custom baseball jersey that fits every athlete—and your season timeline.

At-a-Glance Team Order Checklist

  • Finalize jersey concept (colors, font, number style, trim, sleeve logos).

  • Approve front/back placements (team name, player name, number).

  • Lock roster data (spelling, jersey numbers, captain patches, size runs).

  • Confirm size scale & fit guidance; run quick try-on or size survey.

  • Choose fabric & construction (mesh/performance knit; tackle-twill or sublimated).

  • Set timeline: design → proof → production → delivery (pad for playoffs/weather).

  • Collect payments or budget approvals; consider gift cards for late adds.

  • Approve digital proof(s) and color swatches.

  • Place bulk order with CSV/roster sheet; confirm PO and ship method.

  • Inspect first unit/sample photo; approve for full run.

  • Receive, check counts/sizes, label per player; plan reorders/exchanges.


1) Define the On-Field Identity

1) Define the On-Field Identity

Start with a clear creative brief:

  • Colors & trim: Primary/secondary colors, piping, sleeve cuffs, and collar.

  • Typography: Script or block for TEAM NAME; number font (two-digit readability from 30+ feet).

  • Logos & patches: League logo on sleeve? Captain “C”? Commemorative patch?

  • Compliance: Confirm league rules on name size, number height, and contrasting visibility.

Tip: Gather two or three inspiration photos and annotate them. A good vendor can translate those notes into a sharp, production-ready design.

2) Choose the Build: Fabric & Decoration

Select materials that match how—and where—your team plays:

  • Performance knit or mesh for breathability and moisture management.

  • Decoration:

    • Tackle-twill (classic look, durable, premium feel).

    • Sublimation (lightweight, unlimited colors/graphics, great for gradients and AOP concepts).

  • Reinforcements: Double-needle seams at shoulders/armholes; optional nameplate vs. direct-sewn.

If you have tournaments in hot climates, prioritize lightweight knits and vented panels.

3) Roster Data: Get It Clean the First Time

Create a shared spreadsheet (or use your vendor’s template) with columns for:

  • First Name, Last Name (as printed)

  • Jersey Number (check for conflicts)

  • Size (YS–A4XL), Cut (Men’s/Women’s/Youth if applicable)

  • Optional: Captain, Alt Captain, Sleeve Length, Special Notes
    Freeze spellings early to avoid proof changes later.

4) Sizing Strategy That Actually Works

Two reliable options:

  1. Fit Survey + Size Chart: Have players measure chest/body length; map to the vendor’s chart and choose a consistent ease (e.g., “game-fit = size +1 for chest”).

  2. Sample Kit / Try-On Night: If time allows, nothing beats in-person try-ons. Capture final sizes in the roster sheet on the spot.

Pro move: Set a firm “size lock” date. Late changes create number conflicts and hold up production.

5) Timeline: Work Back from First Pitch

A practical cadence:

  • Design & quote: 2–5 days

  • Proof rounds: 1–3 days (keep stakeholders small to speed approvals)

  • Production: 10–25 business days (decoration method & seasonality matter)

  • Shipping: 2–7 days depending on service

Add a 1-week buffer for weather and courier hiccups. If you must move faster, ask about rush options before approving proofs.

6) Budgeting & Payments (Without Headaches)

  • Confirm unit price tiers by quantity and decoration method.

  • Align on what’s included (names, numbers, sleeve logos) vs. add-ons (extra patches, rush).

  • Collect player payments via team portal or invoicing.

  • For late sign-ups or last-minute gifts, consider a digital gift card option; see the post The Easiest Win: Why a Digital Gift Card Makes the Perfect Custom Jersey Present for a frictionless way to keep momentum without delaying the main order.

7) Proofs: Approve with Confidence

Ask your vendor for:

  • Front/back mockups showing placements and exact typography.

  • Color callouts (Pantone/hex) and fabric notes.

  • Name/number spec (height, twill layers, outline thickness).

Run a final roster-to-proof check: spelling, numbers, captain marks. Approve in writing (“Approved as shown, revision v3”).

8) Placing the Order (Data That Speeds Production)

Submit a clean CSV or vendor template:

  • One row per player with size, number, and any special instructions.

  • A separate tab for patches/logos if needed.

  • Desired in-hand date and shipping address(es).
    Request a written order confirmation: total units, price, ETA, and tracking timeline.

9) Mid-Production Check: Trust but Verify

If possible, get a first-article photo or short video showing:

  • Stitch quality (for tackle-twill).

  • Color accuracy (for sublimation).

  • Placement alignment on a real garment.
    Quick approvals here prevent surprises at delivery.

10) Receiving & Distribution

Upon arrival:

  • Count & check: Verify sizes, numbers, and name spellings.

  • Label per player: Hangtags or polybags with player name/number.

  • Game-day kit: Keep a small repair kit (number decals, needle/thread, spare buttons) for emergencies.

Create a simple exchange policy window for mis-sizes; document any reorders with a new cutoff date.


Smart Extras Coaches Love

  • Coach/Staff polos in matching colors for a unified sideline look.

  • Practice jerseys with simplified decoration to preserve game jerseys.

  • Fan & parent jerseys (same design, alternate fabric) as a booster fundraiser.

  • Number continuity plan for next season to minimize reorder chaos.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

  • Approving proofs before the roster is truly final.

  • Mixing vendor size charts (use the one attached to your order only).

  • Leaving delivery to standard shipping during peak months (upgrade if your first game is close).

  • Over-decorating (shoulder, chest, and sleeve logos together can overcrowd a small youth size).


The Jersey Crafted Advantage

The Jersey Crafted Advantage

At Jersey Crafted, team orders are our home field:

  • Clear proofs, roster-friendly templates, and dependable production windows.

  • Flexible decoration methods for every budget and performance need.

  • Helpful add-ons (staff gear, practice sets, reorders) that keep your look consistent all season.


Copy-Paste Team Order Template

  • Team name / league:

  • Colors (primary/secondary/accent):

  • Decoration (tackle-twill / sublimation):

  • Logos/patches (locations, sizes):

  • Roster tab (Name | Number | Size | Notes):

  • Proof approvers (max 2 people):

  • In-hand date & shipping method:

  • Reorder cutoff date:


custom baseball jersey

Leave a comment